Fire Island Gay Friendly Hotels
A venetian palace at the beach? Men only? Reserve quickly.
Cherry Grove - Bayview Walk , Cherry Grove, NY
Cozy apartments with kitchens for a more complete stay
Cherry Grove - 134 Lewis Walk , Cherry Grove, NY
Step into the Ice Palace!
Cherry Grove - Holly Walk , Cherry Grove, NY
Step Into The Pines, darlings
Fire Island Pines - Atlantic Walk , Fire Island Pines, NY
Beach house turned guesthouse
Fire Island Pines - 22 Atlantic Walk , Fire Island Pines, NY
The Hotels on this page are recommended either by our editors or by our members.