Gay Fire Island
Bars & Clubs
Restaurants
Hotels
Shops
Arts
Beaches
Articles
Events

Cherry Grove Pizza

(11 Ratings)
The only pizza in town, and it's good.
Great garlic knot pies and near all the other gay bars and restaurants


Your support makes our travel guides possible

We believe that LGBTQ+ people deserve safe vacations that allow them to be their authentic selves. That's why our City Guides aren't locked behind a paywall. Can you contribute today?

Cancel anytime · Proudly LGBTQ+ owned and operated

Reviews

snuka12000
snuka12000
Over a year ago

I was pleasantly surprised!

On Fire Island, the food was just okay at the places that I ate at. I was pleasantly surprised by the good quality of the food that I got. For my entree, I got chicken parmigiana which was very good! It hit the spot and it was just what I needed that night. For my appetizer, I got garlic bread with cheese. OMG!!! You must get the garlic bread with cheese if you go there.


Stevin
Stevin
Over a year ago

Good, but not NYC pizza.

Stopped in several times. Great for a lite lunch or a bite before going home. Staff is efficient, friendly, and cute. Definitely hit the spot. Recommended. Review #2. Ate here again in June 2010. Not good. Pizza was dry. Also had a bowl of bland lentil soup. Canned would have been better, I would recommend the pizza after a night out drinking though.


wr9157
wr9157
Over a year ago

Great Pizza

The pizza was so freaking good..nice, flavor and crunchy...the only download price very high..


CBGBFAN
CBGBFAN
Over a year ago

BEST PIZZA IN N.Y. AND THEY SELL WINE

THIS COZY PIZZA PLACE IS PERFECT! SIT OUTSIDE AND ENJOY A SLICE OR GET AN ITALIAN MEAL, REALLY YUMMY. THE HELP IS PART OF THE FAMILY. LOOK FORWARD TO SEEING YOU SOON.


swalloe419
swalloe419
Over a year ago

The Best !!!!

The owner is such a nice guy and the staff is really cool as well ~ The pizza is the best !!!!!! And it is also a great place if you dont have much to spend on meals. Also try Floyds ~ the owner is soooo FKN HOT and the food is great. For great seafood and a great view of the ocean you must go to Jumping Jacks, New owners but still #1


Other Restaurants in Fire Island

Pines Bistro & Martini Bar

Splurge!
Fire Island Pines

Canteen

Lunch by the harbor
Fire Island Pines

The Blue Whale

Fire Island food destination
Fire Island Pines

Island Breeze

Feel the breeze
Cherry Grove

Gay Bars in Fire Island

Sip·n·Twirl

A local institution
Fire Island Pines

Low Tea at the Blue Whale

An island must-do
Fire Island Pines

Cherry's

Must see views
Cherry Grove

The Ice Palace

Longest running LGBTQ+ club in the world
Cherry Grove

Gay Fire Island
Bars & Clubs
Restaurants
Hotels
Shops
Arts
Beaches
Articles
Events