Gay Fire Island
Bars & Clubs
Restaurants
Hotels
Shops
Arts
Beaches
Articles
Events

The Blue Whale

(3 Ratings)
Fire Island food destination
Enjoy a leisurely brunch or a dinner right in the Pines Harbor. The restaurant reflects the islands casual beach environment, and its menu is filled with lite fare, seafood dishes and innovative seasonal offerings. Get ready to party at night, with surprise and regular guests to kick off and highlight your weekend experience!


Your support makes our travel guides possible

We believe that LGBTQ+ people deserve safe vacations that allow them to be their authentic selves. That's why our City Guides aren't locked behind a paywall. Can you contribute today?

Cancel anytime · Proudly LGBTQ+ owned and operated

Reviews

ErinStaceyV
ErinStaceyV
Over a year ago

GREAT food, ambiance and just all-around good times! Make a reservation on the wknds, or you'll have to wait for a table....


skier74
skier74 first review First to Review
Over a year ago

Great food but some pretty horrendous service

Problem is that on weekends, the earliest reservation is at 9pm, after they clear the space from Low Tea. So at 9pm there are a flood of people trying to get seated, and it's absolute chaos. Our party of 5 made a reservation a few hours earlier but still waited 20 minutes to get seated. Then another 20 minutes before our orders were taken; even though there seemed to be plenty of service staff, they all were just prancing around the room, not helping us. This essentially went on all night until we were done with our meal at 12am. Yes -- a 3 hour meal! They need to get their service act together or better manage expectations given the unusual timing here. While the food was excellent, if not rather pricey (to be expected I guess), we probably won't be back unless we hear that the service improves.


Other Restaurants in Fire Island

Canteen

Lunch by the harbor
Fire Island Pines

Pines Bistro & Martini Bar

Splurge!
Fire Island Pines

Cherry Grove Pizza

The only pizza in town, and it's good.
Cherry Grove

Island Breeze

Feel the breeze
Cherry Grove

Gay Bars in Fire Island

Low Tea at the Blue Whale

An island must-do
Fire Island Pines

Sip·n·Twirl

A local institution
Fire Island Pines

Cherry's

Must see views
Cherry Grove

The Ice Palace

Longest running LGBTQ+ club in the world
Cherry Grove

Gay Fire Island
Bars & Clubs
Restaurants
Hotels
Shops
Arts
Beaches
Articles
Events