Gay Friendly Hotels in Fire Island

Belvedere

A venetian palace at the beach? Men only? Reserve quickly.

You'll see the Belvedere as you arrive on the ferry. Its large white towers seem almost out of place here, but...

Nominated for Best of GayCities 2023 - Stay Gay

Cherry Grove · Bayview Walk, Cherry Grove

• outdoor seating
• clothing-optional
• men-only

Cozy apartments with kitchens for a more complete stay

Say for a day, week, month or the whole season in one of the 19 rental apartments at Dune Point. Fire Island is all...

Cherry Grove · 134 Lewis Walk, Cherry Grove

• outdoor seating
• pet-friendly
• hotel

Step into the Ice Palace!

Stay here and you will be in the middle of it all. This is the heart of the Grove, where people come to party, eat...

Cherry Grove · Holly Walk, Cherry Grove

• outdoor seating
• hotel

Step Into The Pines, darlings

The Pines only true hotel, right on the harbor. This simple beach hotel has a great location, just be sure to get out...

Fire Island Pines · Atlantic Walk, Fire Island Pines

• outdoor seating
• hotel

Beach house turned guesthouse

This guest house is a beautiful home opened up to visiting guests. Located next to the ferry and a very short walk to...

Fire Island Pines · 22 Atlantic Walk, Fire Island Pines

• outdoor seating
• bed & breakfast

Landmark gay stay

For over 45 years this charming house has offered a fun and flirty place for nomads, beach bums, and burners to...

Fire Island Pines · 582 Fire Island Blvd, Sayville

• outdoor seating
• bed & breakfast
• men-only
• $$$
• LGBTQ+ owned
• rooftop
• lively
• adults-only