Gay Fire Island
Bars & Clubs
Restaurants
Hotels
Shops
Arts
Beaches
Articles
Events

Your support makes our travel guides possible

We believe that LGBTQ+ people deserve safe vacations that allow them to be their authentic selves. That's why our City Guides aren't locked behind a paywall. Can you contribute today?

Cancel anytime · Proudly LGBTQ+ owned and operated

Reviews

Java
Java
Over a year ago

Stay away

Cherry grove is the place to be. Most of the people who go there are beautiful people. Except for island breeze not to say the people that go here are not good but the managers and owners are definitly people you don't want to know they are homophobes and make fun of and treat gays like pieces of crap. Be careful eating there because I had some scary crap in my plate. I almost choked on it. There are many other options on the island. Please listen and stay the hell away.......


snuka12000
snuka12000
Over a year ago

This is the spot!!!

This is the spot! The view of the South Bay is gorgeous. The staff is friendly and nice! The night that I went there it was open-mic night and they had a live piano player there. The food was very good! I had penne with grilled chicken in a creamy tomato sauce. I definitely recommend that you eat at this spot!


fancypants11
fancypants11
Over a year ago

Correct phone # 631-597-9111

You have made me call the wrong number several times. The correct #631-597-9111


suffolkeats
suffolkeats
Over a year ago

deli style food not good

2 of us ate lunch everything we ate had old bay seasoning in it guess chef grew up during crab season in baltimore ! Tried dinner next day we both agree its ny deli quality food served on a dish but 4x price ! If this restaurant was on mainland in suffolk county it be closed shortly ! Don't waiste you $ their !


markdonovan
markdonovan
Over a year ago

The best meal on the island

Great staff , very warm and welcoming service with a smile and most importantly the meals was great! Compliment to the chef .


Other Restaurants in Fire Island

Cherry Grove Pizza

The only pizza in town, and it's good.
Cherry Grove

Pines Bistro & Martini Bar

Splurge!
Fire Island Pines

Canteen

Lunch by the harbor
Fire Island Pines

The Blue Whale

Fire Island food destination
Fire Island Pines

Gay Bars in Fire Island

Cherry's

Must see views
Cherry Grove

The Ice Palace

Longest running LGBTQ+ club in the world
Cherry Grove

Sip·n·Twirl

A local institution
Fire Island Pines

Low Tea at the Blue Whale

An island must-do
Fire Island Pines

Gay Fire Island
Bars & Clubs
Restaurants
Hotels
Shops
Arts
Beaches
Articles
Events