Gay Fire Island
Bars & Clubs
Restaurants
Hotels
Shops
Arts
Beaches
Articles
Events

Your support makes our travel guides possible

We believe that LGBTQ+ people deserve safe vacations that allow them to be their authentic selves. That's why our City Guides aren't locked behind a paywall. Can you contribute today?

Cancel anytime · Proudly LGBTQ+ owned and operated

Reviews

snuka12000
snuka12000
Over a year ago

The food needs to be better!

I ate lunch there. I am only writing about it as a restaurant. I had chicken wings and fries there. The chicken wings needed to be seasoned more and better. The fries were just okay. I would eat at a different place. The staff was nice and friendly though and the view is nice.


riverboi
riverboi
Over a year ago

Great Place!

I've been going to Cherry's since my first trip to Fire Island in college and it's always a laid back place to have a great mudslide by bartender Johnny Pool or dance on stage or with others. Usually no attitude, just a place to chill and meet new peeps. I recommend it for happy hour and on friday/sat nights. The place is an older crowd usually but there are some young folk there as well and its predominantly women (hence the name) at certain times, either way it's worth checking out.


headhoncho
headhoncho
Over a year ago

Always the place to be

Cherrys, an institution in Cherry Grove is the first place you see getting off the ferry. Always fun, great music, great drinks, great bartenders, including the famous Johny Pool. Come down and try one of the delicious frozen drinks


skier74
skier74
Over a year ago

A lot of fun

Cherry's is always a lot of fun. Very mixed crowd, but everyone just gets along. Great place to dance, drink or just hang out outside on the patio.


swalloe419
swalloe419
Over a year ago

The Best Bar In The Grove !!!!!!!

I've been working and visiting the grove for 11 yrs ~ And since Jackie took over it is packed ~the bartenders are not only HOT but nice as well


Other Gay Bars in Fire Island

The Ice Palace

Longest running LGBTQ+ club in the world
Cherry Grove

Sip·n·Twirl

A local institution
Fire Island Pines

Low Tea at the Blue Whale

An island must-do
Fire Island Pines

Restaurants in Fire Island

Island Breeze

Feel the breeze
Cherry Grove

Cherry Grove Pizza

The only pizza in town, and it's good.
Cherry Grove

Pines Bistro & Martini Bar

Splurge!
Fire Island Pines

Canteen

Lunch by the harbor
Fire Island Pines

The Blue Whale

Fire Island food destination
Fire Island Pines

Gay Fire Island
Bars & Clubs
Restaurants
Hotels
Shops
Arts
Beaches
Articles
Events