Cherry Grove Pizza

 
90% love it
  10
The only pizza in town, and it's good.
Great garlic knot pies and near all the other gay bars and restaurants

Location

    • snuka12000
      snuka12000 Over a year ago
      Loves it

      I was pleasantly surprised!
      On Fire Island, the food was just okay at the places that I ate at. I was pleasantly surprised by the good quality of the food that I got. For my entree, I got chicken parmigiana which was very good! It hit the spot and it was just what I needed that night. For my appetizer, I got garlic bread with cheese. OMG!!! You must get the garlic bread with cheese if you go there.

    • Stevin
      Stevin Over a year ago
      Hates it

      Good, but not NYC pizza.
      Stopped in several times. Great for a lite lunch or a bite before going home. Staff is efficient, friendly, and cute. Definitely hit the spot. Recommended. Review #2. Ate here again in June 2010. Not good. Pizza was dry. Also had a bowl of bland lentil soup. Canned would have been better, I would recommend the pizza after a night out drinking though.

    • wr9157
      wr9157 Over a year ago
      Loves it

      Great Pizza
      The pizza was so freaking good..nice, flavor and crunchy...the only download price very high..

    • CBGBFAN
      CBGBFAN Over a year ago
      Loves it

      BEST PIZZA IN N.Y. AND THEY SELL WINE
      THIS COZY PIZZA PLACE IS PERFECT! SIT OUTSIDE AND ENJOY A SLICE OR GET AN ITALIAN MEAL, REALLY YUMMY. THE HELP IS PART OF THE FAMILY. LOOK FORWARD TO SEEING YOU SOON.

    • swalloe419
      swalloe419 Over a year ago
      Loves it

      The Best !!!!
      The owner is such a nice guy and the staff is really cool as well ~ The pizza is the best !!!!!! And it is also a great place if you dont have much to spend on meals. Also try Floyds ~ the owner is soooo FKN HOT and the food is great. For great seafood and a great view of the ocean you must go to Jumping Jacks, New owners but still #1

    • Versdeguy
      Versdeguy Over a year ago
      Loves it

      Good Pizza
      Good pizza, and reasonable prices too..esp. for over-priced Fire Island. REst of menu quite reasonably priced too...

Tags